Janna Baty as Laura Keene (Mary Dundreary)
Aaron Engebreth as John Coyle (Jack Matthews)
Tom O'Toole as John Wilkes Booth
Alan Schneider as Asa Dundreary (Harry Hawk)
Donald Wilkinson as Abraham Lincoln
Drew Poling as Ned Emerson (Lord Dundreary)
Angela Gooch as Mary Lincoln
Hillarie O'Toole as Gussie
Janice Edwards as Lady Mountchessington
Daniel Kamalic as Doctor Leale